'Forbidden Island' game variants

Charles Roth, 14 Dec 2014       (Techblog top)

I. Introduction
Forbidden Island is a lovely multi-player "cooperative" game in which the players work together to remove mystic treasures from an ancient island before it sinks beneath the waves.  I highly recommend it, especially for people who want a not-too-complicated or not-too-competitive game to play with friends.

Once you've mastered the basic game though, there are several ways to make it more interesting...

II. Alternate island layouts
There's a very interesting discussion at boardgamegeek.com/thread/569926/official-variant-tile-layouts about different ways of arranging the tiles, to make the game more challenging, or at least force players to come up with different strategies.

The 'best' set is shown at the right (click on it to expand to full size), although there are many others.  (I'm particularly fond of the "Bridge of Horrors".)

When using the alternate layouts, you may find it useful to 'mark' sunken tiles, so that you know which spaces are passable by the diver (and which are not).  (Some folks consider the central space in 'Volcano Island' to be lava, and not passable by anyone.)

III. Magic Treasures
The fundamental premise of the game is that trying to remove the 'magic' treasures (figurines) triggers the sinking of the island.  So why not add some 'magic' to the treasures?

Here are additional rules that I have proposed.  They add strategic options, especially in the face of the more difficult layouts (e.g. the Bridge of Horrors).  Each treasure has a specific ability.  If you (an individual player) have a treasure, you can use its power -- once -- by using all three of your actions.

  1. Earth.  Select a tile (you need not be on it).  It must be dry or flooded (not sunken).  Invoking the Earth treasure prevents this tile from ever sinking.

    (Clearly, Fool's Landing is a good choice; but there may be others.)

  2. Water.  This treasure immediately lowers the current water level by one.

  3. Fire.  This treasure reroutes magma underneath the island in such a way as to raise a sunken tile all the way up.  Like Earth, the holder of the treasure selects the tile.  Note that the tile may sink again later in the normal way.

    This means, for example, that even if Fool's Landing sinks, as long as someone can get the fire treasure, the game is not (yet) over.

    It also means that you'll need a way to remember which sunken tiles were where.  (Although practically speaking, using a token for one or two 'key' sunken tiles is usually good enough.)

  4. Air.  This treasure creates a strong wind that opens a path thru the water over sunken tiles (think Moses and the parting of the Red Sea).  All sunken tiles are passable in the normal manner by anyone, through to the end of the treasure-holding player's next turn.